
Cultural
Competency and
Mental Illness
Dr.
Quimby, a
sociologist, has done extensive research on mental health services delivery,
including dual diagnosis, cultural competency, assessment of clinical treatment
models, and supported employment for persons with severe mental illness. Among
his other research interests are HIV/AIDS, criminal justice, and urban social
policy.
Role
of Culture
 |
Culture
refers to identifiable and shared -- although not identical -- patterns of
beliefs, values, behaviors, communication, attitudes, learning, healing, and
other aspects of social interaction.
|
 |
Culture
shapes feelings and actions related to prevention and treatment.
|
 |
Sociological
perspectives may be incorporated into psycho-pharmacological intervention models
of mental illness and substance abuse.
|
Sociological
Perspectives on Culture
 |
Culture
is a fundamental context within which people live and function, and through
which they define themselves and are defined by others.
|
 |
Culture
may have beneficial or harmful elements.
|
 |
Individuals
may have to perform multiple and competing cultural roles.
|
 |
One
needs to be able to negotiate the demands of one's culture(s) or competing
cultures. Successful negotiation is a form of cultural competence. It is crucial
for social interaction, as well as a stable, positive and coherent sense of
self.
|
 |
Culture
is often confused with biological ethnicity or race. It includes history,
values, group and self-identity, language, beliefs, thought patterns, and
behaviors.
|
 |
Culture
involves non-verbal communication, forms of knowledge and ways of knowing,
clinical practices, and social relations.
|
 |
Mental
health treatment and research should include measures of affective competence,
behavioral competence, cognitive competence and cultural competence.
|
 |
Culture
may be explicit or implicit.
|
 |
Culture
may be understood in a political context. Examining culture involves studying
the effects of power on people's perceptions of empowerment, social
legitimization
and self-validation.
|
 |
Culture
affects individuals, e.g., administrators, clinicians, consumers
(patients/clients), researchers, friends, relatives.
It also
affects processes and systems, e.g., institutional culture, policies, service
delivery systems, and patterns of service utilization.
|
 |
Cultural
conditioning and institutional relationships tend to devalue, isolate, and
marginalize persons with severe mental illness.
|
 |
Diversity
exists between and within cultural groups. The broad category of African
Americans or Blacks, for example, contains folks from varied cultural, ethnic
and historical heritages who speak languages, different forms of patois, and
numerous dialects from the Caribbean, Latin America, Europe and Africa.
|
Defining
Cultural Competency
Cultural
competence is a practice or method of working effectively and sensitively within
the cultural context(s) of specific groups. It is an evolving process of
integrating cultural information with research or intervention data and skills.
Benefits
of
Cultural
Competency
Efforts
 |
Achieving cultural competency has the following benefits:
|
 |
Enhancement
of communication styles (oral, non-verbal and written)
|
 |
Improved
interviewing methods
|
 |
More
effective interaction between staff and consumers
|
 |
Greater
engagement and retention of consumers
|
 |
Assessment of
managerial styles of supervisors and case managers
|
 |
Improved case
management functions
|
Significance
of
Cultural
Competency
 |
Grappling
with issues of cultural competency is significant for several reasons:
|
 |
Cultural
competence encompasses interpersonal, clinical, administrative and consumers
levels. It requires knowledge about mental health and healing, communication
skills, adaptive behavior, flexible approaches, self-awareness/consciousness.
|
 |
Cultural
competence requires knowledge of and respect for consumers and practitioners'
attitudes towards health status, medications and therapies .
|
 |
Cultural
competence is a process of awareness, sensitivity, knowledge and application to
address a client's needs and interests. Along with physical and psychological
assessments, the clinician should have basic knowledge of the consumer's
cultural background.
|
 |
Trust
and empowerment of consumers and clinicians are related to the clarity of
purposes, goals, objectives and values of the service agency.
|
 |
Organizational
development, ideological development and political consciousness are linked to
service delivery. Community-based mental health service agencies require
clinicians who are not resistant to and are themselves committed to the
heritages, needs and interests of consumers.
|
 |
Patients/clients/consumers
with severe mental illnesses require witnessing and partnership, as well as
validation and shared power. Many dispossessed persons have common symptoms of
structural devastation, ideological assault and cultural oppression. These signs
may include: Family
fragmentation, erosion
of support structures for working class women, men and children; |
 |
Historical and official dismissal of grievances |
Interrelated
explosive and implosive forms of frustration, aggression and depression.
Recovery
and rehabilitation occur within a context of organic brain damage and cultural
disruption. Treatment involves the development of cultural competency to assist
case managers. Along with primary health care, treatment involves the
rearrangement of thought patterns, the stabilization of community and family
functioning, and experiences which can be culturally interpreted and utilized
for meaningful skills development, healthy social networks and positive
self-identity.
Not
identifying socio-cultural barriers (including those of clinicians) to treatment
may have negative effects for consumers and practitioners, including the
following:
 |
Delayed
entry into treatment; |
 |
Disparities
in health care;
|
 |
Greater
morbidity and mortality rates;
|
 |
Ineffective
service delivery; and |
 |
Under-utilization
of services.
|
Characteristics
of
Cultural
Competency
Cultural competency involves several characteristics. These are:
 |
Recognition
of and respect for cultural differences
|
 |
Cultural
introspection by administrators, supervisors, case managers, vocational
specialists and support staff
|
 |
Awareness
of the differences and issues brought by consumers and service providers
|
 |
Knowledge
about the role of culture in treatment
|
 |
Adaptation
of services which incorporate diverse cultural realities
|
Clinical
Principles
of
Cultural
Competency
Cultural competency includes the following
principles:
 |
Each client is a unique individual.
|
 |
Individuals exist within a cultural context.
|
 |
Treatment involves a holistic perspective of mental, social
and physical health care.
|
 |
Attention to cultural details and knowledge helps to inform
and facilitate engagement and retention of consumers.
|
 |
Mental health treatment involves a relationship between the
consumer and clinician.
|
 |
The care relationship views the consumer as a partner, an
advocate, of the treatment process.
|
 |
Communication between consumers and clinicians is two-way.
|
 |
Both consumer and clinician learn from each other.
|
 |
Families and support groups can promote treatment.
|
 |
Differences and similarities between clinicians and consumers
are recognized, honored, respected and validated.
|
Achieving
Cultural Competency
 |
Develop
cultural portraits of consumers and personnel, including practitioners,
supervisors, administrators and support staff.
|
 |
Conduct
cultural competency workshops for staff.
|
 |
Incorporate
values clarification sessions among staff.
|
 |
Identify
and utilize `cultural informants' who are articulate and have a mental illness.
|
 |
Assess
cultural inoculation and resilience, i.e., evaluate familial and community
factors which help protect persons from experimentation with and abuse of drugs.
|
 |
Hire
a culturally diverse staff, and provide regular education.
|
 |
Minimize
judgments of others.
|
 |
Identify
and confront one's own biases and prejudices.
|
 |
Identify
cultural clues which enhance cultural competence, e.g., non-verbal communication
through body language and facial clues; bilingualism.
|
The
cultural competency of a mental health service delivery agency and its
clinicians can be assessed. Cultural assessments should be an integral aspect of
research and treatment interventions for clients.
Staff
can document culturally based interventions that work, and how to incorporate
sensitivity and information into practice.
Summary
Mental
illness and health occur within cultural contexts. Cultural factors may may be
incorporated into mental health service delivery.
Cultural
competency is a continuous process which can be planned. Education for cultural
competency is necessary for administrators, case managers, support staff and
consumers.
Achieving cultural competency depends on the following:
 |
Commitment displayed by policy makers and administrators
|
 |
Clarity
of the agency's goals, objectives and procedures
|
 |
Generation
of support from staff and consumers
|
 |
Collaborative
planning and communication between consumers and practitioners
|
 |
Creation
of structural mechanisms to monitor and reinforce accomplishments (e.g.,
advisory board)
|
 |
Identification
of cultural attributes of the agency, staff and consumers
|
 |
Assessment
of how cultural factors affect service delivery and utilization
|
 |
Development
of and access to resources and educational opportunities
|
 |
Cultural
matches between consumers and clinicians, when appropriate and feasible
|
 |
Attentiveness
to consumers' perceived spiritual/religious needs and supports
|
 |
Use
of culturally sensitive and relevant materials
|

|